We would appreciate this running on your editorial pages and/or the
Director of Communications
Greenwich Board of Education
290 Greenwich Avenue
Greenwich, CT 06830
e mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
How Good Are the Greenwich Public Schools?
The answer to this question is complicated, but one thing is for certain - you won’t find the answer in invidious school comparisons based on superficial analyses or rankings.
Allow me to state my point more clearly: The standardized test scores upon which so many base the success or failure of a given school are superficial at best. That being said, good standardized tests, such as the Connecticut Mastery Test and the Connecticut Academic Performance Test, measure the achievement of state standards and basic skills, which every student should know and be able to demonstrate. Our objective is to ensure that students achieve mastery of the basic skills and state standards and, further, attain the capacities outlined in the Vision of the Graduate.
As parents and as educators, we ask ourselves – are we providing our students with the skills they will need as they pursue higher education and/or the world of work? We know that the knowledge, skills and experiences that they will need in order to be competitive in the college admissions process or the job market go far beyond what can be measured by any standardized test. We know that the college admissions process is changing – the emphasis on ‘The SAT’ is shifting – there is another standardized test available, the ACT, and some schools are providing other options rather than basing admission decisions on standardized test scores. Colleges are recognizing that standardized testing is not the only or truest predictor of a student’s success. We also know that employers are looking for more than the ‘three R’s’ – they want to see “ the four C’s: Critical thinking and problem solving, Communication, Collaboration, and Creativity*.” Therefore, the question is, how do we measure how well our graduates are prepared to lead productive lives and meet the challenges posed by a rapidly changing global economy?
The starting point for the answer is agreement on what knowledge, skills and attributes every student should have attained upon graduation. That’s why the District adopted its Vision of the Graduate. This one page document summarizes what the Board of Education, parents, community members and district educators believe that each graduate should be striving to achieve upon graduation. We believe that the following indicators should be used to measure the success of our graduates.
- Capstone Projects: The written and performance-based work of students on projects demonstrating mastery of the curriculum rather than multiple choice tests provides a much clearer picture of achievement of a core body of knowledge and our Vision of the Graduate. The District is designing projects for grades five, eight and twelve.
- Longitudinal Data on Graduates: We should be collecting and analyzing longitudinal data to indicate how well prepared our graduates are for college or the world of work. We should be making performance comparisons to our nation’s international rivals rather than our neighboring Districts.
- Empirical evidence provided by standardized assessments (AP, SAT, CMT and CAPT results): Hopefully, these tests will begin to measure what we as a District truly value for our students’ education.
Linda Darling-Hammond, a Stanford professor of education, wrote in an article in The Nation on June 14, 2010 about international comparisons of student achievement. She noted that while student performance using NCLB standardized tests has improved, our international standing has declined. She attributed this to the fact that international assessments demand more advanced analysis than most US tests, and require students to weigh and balance evidence, apply what they know to new problems and explain and defend their answers. This kind of learning is inhibited by lower level multiple choice testing. It is clear to me that we need to achieve a better balance in the assessments we use between content and process.
Our students perform competitively with the highest achieving Districts in the State and in the Nation in venues beyond standardized test scores. The Greenwich Public Schools provide challenging and diverse opportunities for students in all academic, co-curricular, and extra-curricular areas. We provide numerous and diverse academic offerings including more than fifteen Advanced Placement courses. Over 90% of our high school students take three or more years of at least one of seven World Languages offered, including Mandarin Chinese.
Our Mandarin Chinese language program has just been awarded a national grant in recognition of its potential as a model Chinese Language program for the U.S. Our Science program boasts an Honors Science Research Seminar guiding students in conducting significant and in-depth scientific inquiry. At least one student has advanced to the Intel-International Science and Engineering Fair each year for the last four years, resulting in various awards and scholarships. The GHS Math Team is currently pursuing the State Championship Title this year for what would be the third year in a row.
Our “We the People: The Citizen and The Constitution” team has just been named CT State Champions for the fourth year in row – taking them to the National competition in Washington D.C. where they have performed within the top 20 teams across the Nation for the last two years. Our students captured First and Second Place in the 26th annual Shakespeare competition sponsored by the English Speaking Union and Smith College.
Our Theater program was designated for the fourth time in 2010 by the Educational Theater Association as one of the top High School Theater programs in the country. Our vocal and instrumental musicians present award winning performances at the State, Regional and National level, too many to mention here and the high school has been designated as a “Signature School” by the Grammy Foundation.
Our athletic program provides opportunities to participate in 42 different sports and 99 teams, competing for county and State championships regularly in most sports. Most recently, the GHS Girls Swimming Team won both the State Open and Class LL Championships and the Girls Volleyball Team won the Class LL State Championship. The opportunities and achievements of our students in these areas are too numerous and varied to ‘aggregate’ into a single data point, yet they are none-the-less significant as measures of our students’ successes and are consistent with the Vision of the Graduate.
Statistically, there isn’t a lot of difference between our results on standardized tests and the results of comparable districts in Connecticut. On CMT reading, writing and mathematics, 92% of Greenwich students scored at the proficient level and 43% scored at the advanced level; in comparable districts (District Reference Group B), 94% of the students scored at the proficient level and 45% scored at the advanced level. Growth in the reading and mathematics achievement of Greenwich students from the end of third grade to the end of eighth grade compares favorably to the highest performing districts in Connecticut.
The average combined reading and mathematics score of Greenwich students taking the SAT exceed that of DRG B students by 31 points (1134 to 1103). Participation in Advanced Placement courses is higher in Greenwich than in DRG B and the percentage of students qualifying for college credit on AP exams is also higher, 84% as compared to 81%. Given the standard error of measure on standardized tests and differences in student populations, we are in danger of making distinctions without differences among the top performing districts. Is the number one ranked school system based on CMT or CAPT scores in Connecticut the best school system in Connecticut? Not necessarily.
This is not to say that we can’t and shouldn’t improve our standardized test results. We must continuously strive to ensure that each of our students achieve mastery of the basic knowledge and skills assessed on the CMT and the CAPT. We have a strategic plan for improvement that is research based and it is working. We will continue to invest in the solid implementation of these improvement strategies rather than fall prey to a knee-jerk reaction to superficial analyses and external comparisons. We will stay the course. Furthermore, we don’t believe that the measure of our students’ or our schools’ success can be determined by a single standardized test.
I am not making excuses for our test performance. I firmly believe that we will improve our results on standardized tests, but not at the expense of sacrificing meaningful outcomes. Improvement will happen. It will happen because we are strengthening our classroom instruction, aligning our curriculum and focusing on attaining our Vision of the Graduate, all in service of providing each of our students with a rich educational experience.
# # #
Please send your comments, news tips and press releases to GreenwichRoundup@gmail.com